Select Page

Pity The Proud Ones, A Review by Joshua Triliegi | Bureau of Arts and Culture Magazine: October 25, 2011

"I especially enjoyed the characters James and Elizabeth. Dorian and Caroline gave very convincing performances." -Kari

Pity The Proud Ones
Pity the Proud Ones currently playing at The Robey Theatre Company
at LATC Downtown is a complicated story to relay. It is the fourth
play to be produced directly from their writers workshop which develops
and assists writers in the creation of new works. For a play that takes
place in a House of ill repute, it is rather tame. Presented with a formality
fitting for it's period. The subjects of sex, opium, slavery, and politics
are handled almost as if we are watching a play that was written and
performed at the time this play is set : 1915. There is much talk of
history, the Cuban skirmishes of 1898 with Buffalo Soldiers, The impending
war in Europe (WWI), the sinking of the Lucitania, Irish Slaves of 1649 and
the Seminole Indians. But at its core, this is an old fashioned story about
family, secrets, inheritance and manhood. Loyalty, money and racial history
mix together and the weather always plays a part in the moods.

Estranged family members reunite under arduous conditions, in this case,
the eye of a Hurricane. Although the location is set in Florida, it could
be New Orleans, Cuba, maybe even Jamaica, early Australia or other territory
where poor whites, enslaved and newly freed blacks come together, fall in
love, go into business, have children and settle together. Protecting one's
secrets, playing the society game, breaking the codes and getting ones due
all come together in this five person ensemble that is tightly produced and
interesting to watch. Martin O'Grady returns to the outback while a storm
is brewing on the horizon. He was once a reluctant second generation pimp
whom fell in love with his employee and had a son with another woman years
ago. His son is an emancipated young man just a few shades darker than his
irish blooded father. Apparently there is money owed and secrets afloat.

While Martin enjoys his drink and reveling in history, his son James is set
on getting paid and taking to the road with Ella Mae whom works the books
for the local Madame that just happens to be his Dad's ex employee and lover,
Elizabeth Marie. Whom also shares business and pleasure with Pettigrew, the
barkeep and somewhat of a mystery man in this tale. Elizabeth enjoys her pipe
and is somewhat stuck between her past and everyone else's future. Although
this is certainly an ensemble work of literature, the stand out performance
when it comes to tone, period and personification is by Actor Dorian Christian
Baucum playing James, who nails the style and body language in a way that
allows us to truly believe where we are and that this is another time, another
place. These are historical characters, but there is a mythical aspect to them.
James struts and guffaws as if his best friend is the horse he rode on to get here.
With a vocal stylization and stage presence that is both commanding and endearing,
we want him to get his money, pay the Madame and get free. Although his father
is reluctant to do so, he too would like to see his 'boy' become a man and by
the time things are wrapped up, we witness this act. But not before we learn a
few things about Martin's history, "Family is more than just blood", Elizabeth's
journey , "Were all owned by something or someone." and James's dilemma,
"Don't call me boy anymore."

Act two is energized by a Hurricane as well as an inspired performance by
Ben Jurrand whom plays Pettigrew, a physically challenged character whom
has been damaged by history in a way that we hope Jamie does not have to be.
A price that earlier generations paid, so young bucks like James could go out
and kick some ass, as we hear about in the opening scene. Halfway through the
play, Pettigrew repeats the line "I was thinking about discretion, privacy
and the K.K.K.". As if James has not learned of these facts. Although there
is talk of an uncle Pat whom was a priest and a Widow Fernandez whom cooks
up a spicy paella, the play stays within its five person ensemble in a
traditionally structured style and set piece. The work is presented not quite,
'in the round', but perhaps as a two sided experience with the audience on
either side of, and above the players, an interesting choice by the set designer,
Miguel Montalvo, with costumes by Naila Aladdin Sanders. This is a spirited
production which uses its space and ideas smartly and economically.

Caroline Morahan as Elizabeth Marie gives an emotional performance which is
striking, raw and spent, in that her character's passion was used up long ago,
although she is clearly young, lovely and lovable, we see the price she paid
to get this far. One thinks of previous Madame's in famous literature such as,
Steinbeck's East of Eden or Nelson Algren's , Walk on the Wild Side and here
we see something completely different. A limbo state where being in power is
powerless and "Being in love is too costly". She tells us early on. Ella Mae
is played by Staci Mitchell with a quiet reserve. Ella Mae is a business woman
to be, but we get the sense that she will never run a house of ill repute. With
eyes on Jamee or Jamie to her, she could supply him with enough security so that
they may create a family of their own someday. This is a play written with a heavy
past and a certain future for its characters, when it comes to the now moments, there
aren't many. The Hurricane comes and goes, the characters resolve their differences
but the damage done remains. We are left thinking about pasts, presents and uncertain
futures after viewing this work. An interesting piece that conjures history, taboos
and family secrets in an up close and intimate nature. We suggest this Production.
I may even see this play again, later in its run, as director Ben Guillory was present
and taking extensive notes, one gets the sense that this cast is just warming up.